Shingle vs. Metal Roofing

If you're planning a roof replacement, you're probably weighing the pros and cons between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing. Both are excellent choices — but they differ in appearance, cost, durability, and how they perform in wind and hail.

In this guide, we’ll explore each option in detail, compare their wind and hail ratings, and answer some of the most common homeowner questions to help you make an informed decision.

1. Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles remain the most popular roofing material in America, and architectural shingles (also called dimensional or laminate shingles) have come a long way in recent years.

Lifespan

Modern architectural shingles now last 30 to 50 years, especially with proper ventilation and underlayment. They resist curling, cracking, and fading far better than older 3-tab shingles.

Wind Rating

Premium shingles like Tamko Stormfighter FLEX are tested to withstand wind speeds up to 160 mph, thanks to reinforced nailing zones and impact-resistant polymers. That’s strong enough for many hurricane-prone regions.

Hail Resistance

Not all shingles are created equal. Some basic models may only offer Class 1 or 2 impact resistance, but many upgraded shingles — including some by GAF, CertainTeed, and Tamko — are Class 4 rated, meaning they can withstand 2" hail without suffering storm damage.

Cost

Architectural shingles typically cost $5 to $10 per square foot installed, depending on the brand, shingle style, and local labor rates. This makes them the most cost-effective roofing option with good performance.

Types of Shingle Roofing

2. Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is growing in popularity thanks to its unmatched longevity, strength, and sleek modern appearance.

Lifespan

Metal roofs can last 50 to 100 years, depending on the material (steel, aluminum, zinc, copper) and finish. They require minimal maintenance and resist mold, insects, and fire. One advantage of metal roofs is that they can be recoated, extending their lifespan indefinitely at a fraction the cost of replacing the entire roof.

Wind Rating

Properly installed standing seam or interlocking metal panels can withstand wind speeds exceeding 200 mph, making metal one of the best choices for extreme weather.

Hail Resistance

Most metal roofing systems carry a Class 4 impact rating, offering the highest level of protection against hail. Softer metals like aluminum may dent cosmetically but usually won’t suffer structural damage. One potential downfall is that insurance companies are covering what is considered as 'cosmetic damage' less and less, although this is increasingly a more common theme across the industry with roofing in general.

Cost

Metal roofing is 30% to 50% more expensive than asphalt shingles on average. Depending on the profile and materials— and in some cases, it may be 2 to 3 times the cost of a basic shingle roof for higher end options like stone coated metal shingles. However, the longer lifespan and lower maintenance may justify the higher upfront investment.

Note: Prices can vary based on roof complexity, material brand, and region.

Types of Metal Roofing

Common Questions Homeowners Ask

Q: Are metal roofs loud in the rain?

A: Not if properly installed. When installed over solid sheathing and insulation (which is standard in residential roofs), metal roofing is typically no louder than asphalt shingles during rain or hail. The misconception often comes from being under an openly installed metal roof in a barn or porch overhang during rainfall.

Q: Will a metal roof increase my home’s value?

A: Typically, yes. Metal roofing is considered a premium upgrade and can increase resale value thanks to its longevity, durability, and curb appeal — especially in areas prone to storms.

Q: Do metal roofs look too industrial for homes?

A: Modern metal roofing comes in a variety of styles — including metal shingles and textured panels — that mimic the look of tile, slate, or wood, although many homeowners choose standing seam for it's durability and premium look.

Q: Can shingles still be a good choice in storm-prone areas?

A: Absolutely. Impact-rated architectural shingles like Tamko Stormfighter FLEX offer excellent wind and hail resistance, making them a strong and affordable choice for most homeowners.

Final Thoughts: Which Roof Is Right for You?

Ultimately, the right roofing choice depends on a variety of factors — including your personal preferences, how long you plan to stay in the home, local resale trends, and any restrictions set by HOAs. In some neighborhoods, asphalt shingles may be the only approved option due to color or style guidelines. Additionally, homes with complex rooflines featuring multiple steep angles and valleys can significantly increase installation labor and material waste for metal roofing, making shingles a more practical solution.

That said, metal roofing remains an excellent investment for many homeowners seeking superior durability, energy efficiency, and long-term value. And with recent advancements in shingle technology, high-performance asphalt shingles now offer impressive wind and hail resistance — making them a close second.

Both systems can be a smart choice — the best option is the one that aligns with your home’s design, your budget, and your long-term plans.

Still not sure?
Contact KC Roofing Systems Inc. today for a free, no-pressure consultation and roof inspection. We'll help you choose the best roofing system for your budget, location, and goals — with expert installation and long-term peace of mind.